SIMULATED FIXTURE · NOT A LIVE AUDIT

A report to act on.

Simulated website and content evidence. No live customer data.

01 / SCOPE & STATUS

Exactly what was obtained.

partial
SELECTED SCOPE3 pagesExact URLs selected by you
EVIDENCE CREATED · UTCExpiry: Not applicable: fictional public sample
HTML GENERATED · UTCGeneration time is not acquisition time.
WEBSITE EVIDENCE

The numbers behind this report.

Rule states, not a GEO score

Technical checks

30 instances
Technical rule states. Confirmed pass: 15. Confirmed issue: 2. Needs review: 4. Not obtained: 1. Not run: 3. Not applicable: 5.
15 Confirmed pass2 Confirmed issue4 Needs review1 Not obtained3 Not run5 Not applicable
Technical pass rate · 15 / 17. pass / pass + fail instances.

Technical pass rate

88.24%

15 / 17 pass / pass + fail instances

Determined coverage · 17 / 25. determined / applicable planned instances.

Determined coverage

68.00%

17 / 25 determined / applicable planned instances

Content review

25 instances
Content rule states. Confirmed pass: 0. Confirmed issue: 0. Needs review: 25. Not obtained: 0. Not run: 0. Not applicable: 0.
0 Confirmed pass0 Confirmed issue25 Needs review0 Not obtained0 Not run0 Not applicable
43distinct retained evidence itemsReview content evidence ↗

One count per unique rule instance. Unknown and unrun checks are neither pass nor fail. Content states describe review status, not content quality.

AI ANSWER EVIDENCE SIMULATED · NO LIVE SAMPLES

Evidence for each platform.

Inspect answers ↗

ChatGPT

Imported evidence

12 provided · 10 valid · 2 failed

Planned samples provided SIMULATED

Brand mention
30.00% Brand mention · Complete plan; valid records only. 3 / 10 positive / judgeableComplete plan; valid records only
Original citation
20.00% Original citation · Complete plan; valid records only. 2 / 10 positive / judgeableComplete plan; valid records only
Valid-plan coverage
83.33%10 / 12 valid / plannedSampling manifest supplied; recorded failures remain excluded from valid records.
Sampling conditions
Mode
web_search
Questions
Non-brand commercial
Region / language
US / en-US
Model
Not disclosed
View group

Perplexity

Imported evidence

12 provided · 12 valid · 0 failed

Planned samples provided SIMULATED

Brand mention
58.33% Brand mention · Complete plan; valid records only. 7 / 12 positive / judgeableComplete plan; valid records only
Original citation
41.67% Original citation · Complete plan; valid records only. 5 / 12 positive / judgeableComplete plan; valid records only
Valid-plan coverage
100.00%12 / 12 valid / plannedSampling manifest supplied; recorded failures remain excluded from valid records.
Sampling conditions
Mode
web_search
Questions
Non-brand commercial
Region / language
US / en-US
Model
Not disclosed
View group

Gemini

Imported evidence

12 provided · 10 valid · 2 failed

Planned samples provided SIMULATED

Brand mention
30.00% Brand mention · Complete plan; valid records only. 3 / 10 positive / judgeableComplete plan; valid records only
Original citation
33.33% Original citation · Judgeable subset only. 4 unknown, excluded from judgeable denominator. 2 / 6 positive / judgeableJudgeable subset only · 4 unknown6 / 10 valid records judgeable · 60.00% judgment coverage
Valid-plan coverage
83.33%10 / 12 valid / plannedSampling manifest supplied; recorded failures remain excluded from valid records.
Sampling conditions
Mode
web_search
Questions
Non-brand commercial
Region / language
GB / en-GB
Model
Not disclosed
View group

Claude

Imported evidence

8 provided · 6 valid · 2 failed

Incomplete plan SIMULATED

Brand mention
33.33% Brand mention · Judgeable subset only. 2 / 6 positive / judgeableJudgeable subset only
Original citation
0.00% Original citation · Judgeable subset only. 0 / 6 positive / judgeableJudgeable subset only
Valid-plan coverage
50.00%6 / 12 valid / plannedSampling manifest supplied; recorded failures remain excluded from valid records.
Sampling conditions
Mode
plain_chat
Questions
Brand questions
Region / language
US / en-US
Model
Not disclosed
View group

No platform was sampled automatically. Website checks do not measure AI mentions or citations. Simulated answer evidence; no platforms were sampled. Source unverified. Separate samples; no combined platform score.

01
INPUT URL

https://northstar.example/product

FINAL URL

https://northstar.example/product

Mode: Controlled fixture · no live page was fetched · Observed: 2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00 · HTTP: 200 · Complete: True

02
INPUT URL

https://northstar.example/implementation

FINAL URL

https://northstar.example/implementation

Mode: Controlled fixture · no live page was fetched · Observed: 2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00 · HTTP: 200 · Complete: True

03
INPUT URL

https://northstar.example/guide

FINAL URL

https://northstar.example/guide

Mode: Controlled fixture · no live page was fetched · Observed: 2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00 · HTTP: 200 · Complete: True

SIMULATED platform scenarios. ChatGPT illustrates a complete plan with failures; Perplexity a fully valid plan; Gemini incomplete citation capture; Claude a partial plan. These differences are fictional test conditions, not measured provider performance. No AI platform was sampled.

Unique page/rule instances are counted once. Unknown and not_run are neither pass nor fail. Content and AI counts use separate definitions.

02 / ISSUES & NEXT STEPS

What needs attention.

2confirmed issues

Start with the confirmed rule failures below. Review actions require a decision before editing.

Confirmed issues 2

Repair the invalid JSON-LD block

Confirmed · P2
Observation & why it matters

Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.

Present JSON-LD parses as objects or arrays.

Saved evidence
{'blocks': 1, 'types': [], 'errors': [{'block': 0, 'error': 'JSONDecodeError'}], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Next step

Locate JSON-LD block 1 in the saved script (raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]). Recorded parser/shape issue: JSONDecodeError. Repair the indicated block and verify its facts.

Acceptance check

Re-fetch this exact URL and parse the corrected JSON-LD block 1; verify the recorded error is absent and retained JSON-LD types remain intentional. Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Owner, dependencies & original finding
Responsible role
Developer
Needed before editing
Confirm page intent and locate the responsible CMS/template setting before editing.
Implementation location
CMS / template / file: to be located.
Original rule
R06 v1.0.0 · fail
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Evidence mode
controlled_fixture
Locate the original R06 evidence →

Add a document title for this page

Confirmed · P2
Observation & why it matters

Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.

A descriptive title with reviewed headings, language and purpose.

Saved evidence
{'titles': [], 'h1': ['Northstar workspace for support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1408, 'possible_js_shell': False}
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
raw_html: title, h1, html[lang]
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Next step

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Acceptance check

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Owner, dependencies & original finding
Responsible role
Content editor
Needed before editing
Confirm page intent and locate the responsible CMS/template setting before editing.
Implementation location
CMS / template / file: to be located.
Original rule
R08 v1.0.0 · fail
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Evidence mode
controlled_fixture
Locate the original R08 evidence →

Specific review actions 3

Check the specific heading transitions and repeated passages

Review before editing
Observation & why it matters

Retained HTML contains 1 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups.

The structure is observable; intentional nesting and useful policy reuse still require an editor's decision.

Saved evidence
What the workspace does
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)
Context
Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Saved evidence
Plan options
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1)
Context
Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Next step

Compare the cited headings with their section relationship. Change the level only if it misrepresents that relationship. For repeated text, document its purpose; remove or consolidate only unnecessary repetition.

Acceptance check

The editor records a decision for each cited transition/reuse. Re-extraction matches the intended outline and any retained repetition has an explanation.

Owner, dependencies & original finding
Responsible role
Content editor / business owner
Needed before editing
Editor confirms section nesting and whether reuse is intentional.
Implementation location
CMS / template / file: to be located.
Original rule
C03 v2.0.0 · needs review
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Evidence mode
controlled_fixture
Locate the original C03 evidence →

Reconcile the cited amounts under matching offer conditions

Review before editing
Observation & why it matters

1 currency groups contain different literal amounts; a like-for-like conflict has not been established.

Different products, tiers, regions, historic prices and quotations can legitimately have different amounts.

Saved evidence
Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)
Context
Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Saved evidence
The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/product
Raw-source location
html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)
Context
Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.
Snapshot
sample-product.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Next step

For each cited amount, record product/variant, package, region and effective date. Compare only matching offers with the owner's dated price record; correct or qualify text only after confirming a mismatch.

Acceptance check

Each compared statement has an offer/region/date label and an authoritative record; any verified conflict is corrected, or the legitimate difference is documented.

Owner, dependencies & original finding
Responsible role
Business owner / content editor
Needed before editing
Business owner supplies dated offer facts; editor preserves negation, quotation and historical context.
Implementation location
CMS / template / file: to be located.
Original rule
C04 v2.0.0 · needs review
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Evidence mode
controlled_fixture
Locate the original C04 evidence →

Verify the source behind these exact claim candidates

Review before editing
Observation & why it matters

1 retained claim candidates have unverified source support.

A number or nearby link identifies review work; it does not prove the statement is false or supported.

Saved evidence
There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
Locate this evidenceOpen this saved source item →
URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Raw-source location
html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)
Context
Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
Snapshot
sample-guide.json
Saved-byte SHA-256
3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

A hash detects changes to saved bytes; it does not prove source authenticity.

Next step

Open the cited passage in context. Identify claim ownership, then record the original source and exact supporting passage, date, method and conditions. Qualify or remove the claim only if that review establishes a problem.

Acceptance check

The reviewer records a support decision, source passage and applicable conditions for each candidate. Unsupported wording is corrected with owner approval.

Owner, dependencies & original finding
Responsible role
Content editor / business owner
Needed before editing
Claim owner supplies the original supporting source; editor verifies quotations, denials and historical context.
Implementation location
CMS / template / file: to be located.
Original rule
C05 v2.0.0 · needs review
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Evidence mode
controlled_fixture
Locate the original C05 evidence →

Actions use saved selected-page evidence. Review tasks are not confirmed defects; no traffic, ranking or AI-citation gain is predicted. Showing 5 of 14 available actions; all original findings remain below.

03 / WEBSITE EVIDENCE

The technical foundation.

Inspect technical observations 30 saved findings
R01HTTP response and completenesshttps://northstar.example/productpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R01 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

An HTTP response does not establish indexing.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.status_code; response.headers; response.complete
{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "complete": true,
  "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
  "error": null,
  "http_status": 200
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Complete successful HTML response
Severity basis
An HTTP response does not establish indexing.
Finding ID
d413c9450790264d9d68
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete

{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}

Original rule guidance

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R02Redirect path and scopehttps://northstar.example/productpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R02 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Saved redirects describe observed routing only.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.redirect_chain
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
The selected URL resolves within the permitted scope and limits.
Severity basis
Saved redirects describe observed routing only.
Finding ID
5f6ebca3bec4db4de8b4
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

response.redirect_chain

[]

Original rule guidance

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R04Indexing directives and intenthttps://northstar.example/productpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R04 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag
{'meta': [{'name': 'robots', 'content': 'index'}], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}
Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_intent": null,
  "header_directives": [],
  "meta": [
    {
      "content": "index",
      "name": "robots"
    }
  ],
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "x_robots_tag": ""
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

SEO owner / developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Observed directives agree with explicitly confirmed indexing intent.
Severity basis
Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.
Finding ID
1d8e50e4043afa95a54b
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag

{'meta': [{'name': 'robots', 'content': 'index'}], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}

Original rule guidance

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R05Canonical declarationshttps://northstar.example/productpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R05 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link
{'declarations': ['https://northstar.example/product'], 'resolved': ['https://northstar.example/product'], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'http_link': ''}
Saved observation data
{
  "base_url": "https://northstar.example/product",
  "declarations": [
    "https://northstar.example/product"
  ],
  "http_link": "",
  "resolved": [
    "https://northstar.example/product"
  ]
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
One unambiguous valid canonical declaration.
Severity basis
A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.
Finding ID
07428caad57d79523fd2
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link

{'declarations': ['https://northstar.example/product'], 'resolved': ['https://northstar.example/product'], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'http_link': ''}

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R06Structured data syntax and typeshttps://northstar.example/productfail
P2 · medium severitycontrolled_fixture · R06 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]
{'blocks': 1, 'types': [], 'errors': [{'block': 0, 'error': 'JSONDecodeError'}], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "blocks": 1,
  "duplicate_keys": [],
  "errors": [
    {
      "block": 0,
      "error": "JSONDecodeError"
    }
  ],
  "same_id_differences": [],
  "traversal_limited": false,
  "types": []
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Locate JSON-LD block 1 in the saved script (raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]). Recorded parser/shape issue: JSONDecodeError. Repair the indicated block and verify its facts.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-fetch this exact URL and parse the corrected JSON-LD block 1; verify the recorded error is absent and retained JSON-LD types remain intentional. Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Present JSON-LD parses as objects or arrays.
Severity basis
Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.
Finding ID
09b5500826368d7afa8b
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]

{'blocks': 1, 'types': [], 'errors': [{'block': 0, 'error': 'JSONDecodeError'}], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}

Original rule guidance

Repair the indicated block and verify its facts.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R07Raw and rendered contenthttps://northstar.example/productnot_run
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R07 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)
{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "dom_differs": null,
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "rendered": false,
  "rendered_snapshot_ref": null
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Separate raw and rendered observations before judging final content.
Severity basis
Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.
Finding ID
c673f42bd7817f44188e
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}

Original rule guidance

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R08Title, headings and languagehttps://northstar.example/productfail
P2 · medium severitycontrolled_fixture · R08 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: title, h1, html[lang]
{'titles': [], 'h1': ['Northstar workspace for support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1408, 'possible_js_shell': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "h1": [
    "Northstar workspace for support teams"
  ],
  "lang": "en-US",
  "possible_js_shell": false,
  "raw_text_chars": 1408,
  "titles": []
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
A descriptive title with reviewed headings, language and purpose.
Severity basis
Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.
Finding ID
8db9361353c5822cbe2a
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: title, h1, html[lang]

{'titles': [], 'h1': ['Northstar workspace for support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1408, 'possible_js_shell': False}

Original rule guidance

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R10Confirmed business factshttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R10 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Literal page claims agree with user-confirmed business facts.
Severity basis
Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.
Finding ID
919ad45efe1723d7da81
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]

Original rule guidance

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R12Selected claims and sourceshttps://northstar.example/productnot_applicable
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R12 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
not_applicable
Expected condition
Selected claims have verified original sources, dates and context.
Severity basis
Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.
Finding ID
37fdedb113eeadd0e967
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims

[]

Original rule guidance

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R01HTTP response and completenesshttps://northstar.example/implementationpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R01 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

An HTTP response does not establish indexing.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.status_code; response.headers; response.complete
{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "complete": true,
  "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
  "error": null,
  "http_status": 200
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Complete successful HTML response
Severity basis
An HTTP response does not establish indexing.
Finding ID
8e1774e07a2cabf23080
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete

{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}

Original rule guidance

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R02Redirect path and scopehttps://northstar.example/implementationpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R02 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Saved redirects describe observed routing only.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.redirect_chain
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
The selected URL resolves within the permitted scope and limits.
Severity basis
Saved redirects describe observed routing only.
Finding ID
05481fb8adef53893efc
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

response.redirect_chain

[]

Original rule guidance

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R04Indexing directives and intenthttps://northstar.example/implementationpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R04 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag
{'meta': [], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}
Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_intent": null,
  "header_directives": [],
  "meta": [],
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "x_robots_tag": ""
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

SEO owner / developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Observed directives agree with explicitly confirmed indexing intent.
Severity basis
Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.
Finding ID
c089052df91c96694309
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag

{'meta': [], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}

Original rule guidance

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R05Canonical declarationshttps://northstar.example/implementationpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R05 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link
{'declarations': ['https://northstar.example/implementation'], 'resolved': ['https://northstar.example/implementation'], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'http_link': ''}
Saved observation data
{
  "base_url": "https://northstar.example/implementation",
  "declarations": [
    "https://northstar.example/implementation"
  ],
  "http_link": "",
  "resolved": [
    "https://northstar.example/implementation"
  ]
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
One unambiguous valid canonical declaration.
Severity basis
A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.
Finding ID
242d0c1d626e158d89de
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link

{'declarations': ['https://northstar.example/implementation'], 'resolved': ['https://northstar.example/implementation'], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'http_link': ''}

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R06Structured data syntax and typeshttps://northstar.example/implementationnot_applicable
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R06 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]
{'blocks': 0, 'types': [], 'errors': [], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "blocks": 0,
  "duplicate_keys": [],
  "errors": [],
  "same_id_differences": [],
  "traversal_limited": false,
  "types": []
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Keep structured facts consistent with visible content.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
not_applicable
Expected condition
Present JSON-LD parses as objects or arrays.
Severity basis
Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.
Finding ID
2c1ee8098b8ab1232c46
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]

{'blocks': 0, 'types': [], 'errors': [], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}

Original rule guidance

Keep structured facts consistent with visible content.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R07Raw and rendered contenthttps://northstar.example/implementationnot_run
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R07 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)
{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "dom_differs": null,
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "rendered": false,
  "rendered_snapshot_ref": null
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Separate raw and rendered observations before judging final content.
Severity basis
Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.
Finding ID
aab6faca356efc291f05
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}

Original rule guidance

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R08Title, headings and languagehttps://northstar.example/implementationpass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R08 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: title, h1, html[lang]
{'titles': ['Northstar implementation service'], 'h1': ['A guided setup for small support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1051, 'possible_js_shell': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "h1": [
    "A guided setup for small support teams"
  ],
  "lang": "en-US",
  "possible_js_shell": false,
  "raw_text_chars": 1051,
  "titles": [
    "Northstar implementation service"
  ]
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
A descriptive title with reviewed headings, language and purpose.
Severity basis
Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.
Finding ID
5f71ca74513dc315804a
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: title, h1, html[lang]

{'titles': ['Northstar implementation service'], 'h1': ['A guided setup for small support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1051, 'possible_js_shell': False}

Original rule guidance

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R10Confirmed business factshttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R10 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Literal page claims agree with user-confirmed business facts.
Severity basis
Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.
Finding ID
904995bdffe26ef46a33
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]

Original rule guidance

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R12Selected claims and sourceshttps://northstar.example/implementationnot_applicable
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R12 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
not_applicable
Expected condition
Selected claims have verified original sources, dates and context.
Severity basis
Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.
Finding ID
85ba7192ef1e553cc169
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims

[]

Original rule guidance

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R01HTTP response and completenesshttps://northstar.example/guidepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R01 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

An HTTP response does not establish indexing.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.status_code; response.headers; response.complete
{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "complete": true,
  "content_type": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
  "error": null,
  "http_status": 200
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Complete successful HTML response
Severity basis
An HTTP response does not establish indexing.
Finding ID
8af7b5c5b20b65af343b
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete

{'http_status': 200, 'content_type': 'text/html; charset=utf-8', 'complete': True, 'error': None}

Original rule guidance

Inspect access policy and the exact response; resolve observed failure if unintended.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R01 v1.0.0; inspect response.status_code; response.headers; response.complete.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R02Redirect path and scopehttps://northstar.example/guidepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R02 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Saved redirects describe observed routing only.

SOURCE EXCERPTresponse.redirect_chain
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
The selected URL resolves within the permitted scope and limits.
Severity basis
Saved redirects describe observed routing only.
Finding ID
f4c6d46c1b2c598d5a23
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

response.redirect_chain

[]

Original rule guidance

Review route configuration; keep the requested page scope explicit.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R02 v1.0.0; inspect response.redirect_chain.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R04Indexing directives and intenthttps://northstar.example/guidepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R04 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag
{'meta': [], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}
Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_intent": null,
  "header_directives": [],
  "meta": [],
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "x_robots_tag": ""
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

SEO owner / developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Observed directives agree with explicitly confirmed indexing intent.
Severity basis
Intentional noindex is not automatically a defect. Raw directives are preserved even if a later DOM differs.
Finding ID
697549e4bcb819994e33
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag

{'meta': [], 'x_robots_tag': '', 'confirmed_intent': None, 'raw_noindex': False, 'header_directives': []}

Original rule guidance

Confirm intent and crawler scope, then locate and correct only conflicting source/header directives.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R04 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: meta[name]; response.headers.x-robots-tag.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R05Canonical declarationshttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R05 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link
{'declarations': [], 'resolved': [], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'http_link': ''}
Saved observation data
{
  "base_url": "https://northstar.example/guide",
  "declarations": [],
  "http_link": "",
  "resolved": []
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
One unambiguous valid canonical declaration.
Severity basis
A declared canonical does not establish Google's selected canonical.
Finding ID
8db77af0c59d87b4e3b6
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link

{'declarations': [], 'resolved': [], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'http_link': ''}

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R06Structured data syntax and typeshttps://northstar.example/guidenot_applicable
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R06 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]
{'blocks': 0, 'types': [], 'errors': [], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "blocks": 0,
  "duplicate_keys": [],
  "errors": [],
  "same_id_differences": [],
  "traversal_limited": false,
  "types": []
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Keep structured facts consistent with visible content.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
not_applicable
Expected condition
Present JSON-LD parses as objects or arrays.
Severity basis
Syntax and declared types do not prove factual quality or citation.
Finding ID
09821e9989587d0b2844
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]

{'blocks': 0, 'types': [], 'errors': [], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}

Original rule guidance

Keep structured facts consistent with visible content.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R07Raw and rendered contenthttps://northstar.example/guidenot_run
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R07 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)
{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Saved observation data
{
  "dom_differs": null,
  "raw_noindex": false,
  "rendered": false,
  "rendered_snapshot_ref": null
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Separate raw and rendered observations before judging final content.
Severity basis
Live JavaScript rendering is not implemented; supplied DOM fixtures are simulations.
Finding ID
2f77530710fdb6ba5dae
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}

Original rule guidance

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R08Title, headings and languagehttps://northstar.example/guidepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R08 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: title, h1, html[lang]
{'titles': ['How to compare support reporting tools'], 'h1': ['How to compare support reporting tools'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 934, 'possible_js_shell': False}
Saved observation data
{
  "h1": [
    "How to compare support reporting tools"
  ],
  "lang": "en-US",
  "possible_js_shell": false,
  "raw_text_chars": 934,
  "titles": [
    "How to compare support reporting tools"
  ]
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
A descriptive title with reviewed headings, language and purpose.
Severity basis
Only raw title, headings and language were observed; semantic purpose needs owner review.
Finding ID
ed4aa93c5ce90a8ecc69
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: title, h1, html[lang]

{'titles': ['How to compare support reporting tools'], 'h1': ['How to compare support reporting tools'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 934, 'possible_js_shell': False}

Original rule guidance

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R10Confirmed business factshttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R10 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Literal page claims agree with user-confirmed business facts.
Severity basis
Only a whole conflicting statement with explicitly user-confirmed context is a failure; phrases, negation and missing expected wording need review.
Finding ID
1a467a839f59b134f742
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]

Original rule guidance

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R12Selected claims and sourceshttps://northstar.example/guidenot_applicable
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R12 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
not_applicable
Expected condition
Selected claims have verified original sources, dates and context.
Severity basis
Attribution and source quality require human review. No claim inventory was inferred.
Finding ID
04d3c64923e96274af48
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims

[]

Original rule guidance

Locate each selected claim's original source, date and surrounding context; confirm it with the content owner.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R12 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text offsets; user_selected_claims.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R03Robots acquisition and policysite:northstar.examplepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R03 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Audit, search and training user agents are separate. Disallow can be intentional.

SOURCE EXCERPTsnapshots: each page.robots
[{'page': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow: /\n'}}, {'page': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow: /\n'}}, {'page': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow
Saved observation data
[
  {
    "page": "https://northstar.example/product",
    "robots": {
      "allowed": true,
      "status": "fetched",
      "user_agent": "EvidenceAuditBot"
    }
  },
  {
    "page": "https://northstar.example/implementation",
    "robots": {
      "allowed": true,
      "status": "fetched",
      "user_agent": "EvidenceAuditBot"
    }
  },
  {
    "page": "https://northstar.example/guide",
    "robots": {
      "allowed": true,
      "status": "fetched",
      "user_agent": "EvidenceAuditBot"
    }
  }
]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm intended bot policies; re-fetch robots and test each selected path for the exact user agent.

SEO owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R03 v1.0.0; inspect snapshots: each page.robots.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
site:northstar.example
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Robots policy is observed for each selected path and named user agent.
Severity basis
Audit, search and training user agents are separate. Disallow can be intentional.
Finding ID
cae9f506ebe5da167471
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json
sample-product.json
sample-implementation.json
sample-guide.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

snapshots: each page.robots

[{'page': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow: /\n'}}, {'page': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow: /\n'}}, {'page': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'robots': {'status': 'fetched', 'allowed': True, 'user_agent': 'EvidenceAuditBot', 'body': 'User-agent: *\nAllow

Original rule guidance

Confirm intended bot policies; re-fetch robots and test each selected path for the exact user agent.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R03 v1.0.0; inspect snapshots: each page.robots.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R09Links within the selected scopesite:northstar.examplepass
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R09 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

No link in this selected scope does not establish a site-wide orphan.

SOURCE EXCERPTraw_html: a[href] across selected page snapshots
{'selected_urls': ['https://northstar.example/guide', 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'https://northstar.example/product'], 'observed_links': [{'from': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/implementation'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/guide'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/product'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'to': 'https://nort
Saved observation data
{
  "no_observed_incoming_link": [],
  "observed_links": [
    {
      "from": "https://northstar.example/product",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
    },
    {
      "from": "https://northstar.example/product",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/guide"
    },
    {
      "from": "https://northstar.example/implementation",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/product"
    },
    {
      "from": "https://northstar.example/guide",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/product"
    },
    {
      "from": "https://northstar.example/guide",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
    }
  ],
  "selected_urls": [
    "https://northstar.example/guide",
    "https://northstar.example/implementation",
    "https://northstar.example/product"
  ]
}
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review navigation intent and add contextual links only where useful; re-check the same selected pages.

Content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R09 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: a[href] across selected page snapshots.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
site:northstar.example
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Selected-page links support the intended navigation.
Severity basis
No link in this selected scope does not establish a site-wide orphan.
Finding ID
a9d0fc9dbba8f8bac184
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json
sample-product.json
sample-implementation.json
sample-guide.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

raw_html: a[href] across selected page snapshots

{'selected_urls': ['https://northstar.example/guide', 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'https://northstar.example/product'], 'observed_links': [{'from': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/implementation'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/product', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/guide'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/implementation', 'to': 'https://northstar.example/product'}, {'from': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'to': 'https://nort

Original rule guidance

Review navigation intent and add contextual links only where useful; re-check the same selected pages.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R09 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: a[href] across selected page snapshots.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

R11Sitemap and auxiliary filessite:northstar.exampleunknown
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · R11 v1.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Only /sitemap.xml and /llms.txt were attempted. Missing llms.txt is not Google AI eligibility failure.

SOURCE EXCERPTauxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML
[]
Saved observation data
[]
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Locate the site's actual sitemap if elsewhere; repair only observed XML errors; do not infer indexation.

Developer

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R11 v1.0.0; inspect auxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
site:northstar.example
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Selected auxiliary files have an observed acquisition and parse state.
Severity basis
Only /sitemap.xml and /llms.txt were attempted. Missing llms.txt is not Google AI eligibility failure.
Finding ID
535ec24391732453fe3e
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

auxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML

[]

Original rule guidance

Locate the site's actual sitemap if elsewhere; repair only observed XML errors; do not infer indexation.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R11 v1.0.0; inspect auxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

04 / CONTENT EVIDENCE

Observation and judgment.

Structural observations and confirmed facts stay separate from semantic and business review.

Explore the content evidence map
Inspect content observations 25 saved findings
C01Purpose and audiencehttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C01 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 5 retained headings and 2 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)
Northstar workspace for support teams
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "basis": "Literal action wording; intended primary action not established",
      "context": "This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "https://northstar.example/contact",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "Request a plan review",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "footer",
      "basis": "Literal action wording; intended primary action not established",
      "context": "Privacy Contact Northstar",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "mailto:help@northstar.example",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e footer:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "Contact Northstar",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "context": {
    "audience": "US support team operations managers",
    "business_context": "Fictional owner confirms that Starter and Team, assisted and self-serve, and US and UK are different offers. Historical prices must retain their dates.",
    "confirmed": true,
    "page_type": "product",
    "primary_action": "Request a plan review",
    "purpose": "Compare a suitable workspace plan",
    "questions": [
      "Which plan fits my team?",
      "What preparation and limits apply?",
      "What supports the review-speed claim?"
    ],
    "source_status": "confirmed_user",
    "truncated": false
  },
  "observed_heading_outline": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "US"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 1,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h1:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Northstar workspace for support teams",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "US"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "What the workspace does",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 4,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h4:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Plan options",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "A fictional reviewer wrote: \"We resolved 50% more issues during one trial.\" This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result. Evidence behind our claims Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": true,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Evidence behind our claims",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here. Before you choose All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Before you choose",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "observed_titles": [],
  "semantic_alignment": "not_automatically_determined",
  "type_candidates": []
}
Locate 8 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar workspace for support teams

Context: Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

What the workspace does

Context: Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1)

Plan options

Context: Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 4 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

Evidence behind our claims

Context: A fictional reviewer wrote: "We resolved 50% more issues during one trial." This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result. Evidence behind our claims Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 5 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

Before you choose

Context: Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here. Before you choose All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 6 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

Context: Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 7 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Request a plan review

Context: This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 8 · C01

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(2)

Contact Northstar

Context: Privacy Contact Northstar

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Who should use this specific page, and what should they be able to do after reading it?
  • Do the cited title, introduction and action communicate the same intended task?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 5 retained headings and 2 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.
Finding ID
8924d603a7c57f9f1a86
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

Northstar workspace for support teams

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C02Questions and answer evidencehttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C02 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

3 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)
The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.
Question-to-passage map 3 confirmed questions

Literal overlap retrieves candidates only. Heading text alone is not a verified answer, and no candidate does not prove the page lacks an answer.

  1. Which plan fits my team?

    3 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)
    The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.
    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)
    Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.
    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)
    The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.
  2. What preparation and limits apply?

    0 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    No literal-overlap candidate was retrieved in the retained inventory. Review the saved page before deciding whether there is a content gap.

  3. What supports the review-speed claim?

    0 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    No literal-overlap candidate was retrieved in the retained inventory. Review the saved page before deciding whether there is a content gap.

Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_question_count": 3,
  "coverage": null,
  "question_checks": [
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [
        {
          "area": "main",
          "context": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [
              "2024",
              "historical"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "no"
            ],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "matching_words": [
            "plan",
            "team"
          ],
          "retained_word_count": 12,
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(4)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "area": "main",
          "context": "What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [
              "Plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "matching_words": [
            "team"
          ],
          "retained_word_count": 20,
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(2)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "area": "main",
          "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [
              "Plan",
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "matching_words": [
            "plan"
          ],
          "retained_word_count": 23,
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
          "text_truncated": false
        }
      ],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "Which plan fits my team?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    },
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "What preparation and limits apply?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    },
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "What supports the review-speed claim?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    }
  ],
  "requirements": "No universal price, FAQ or word-count requirement is applied.",
  "unconfirmed_questions_retained": []
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C02

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Context: The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C02

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.

Context: What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C02

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.

Context: Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does each retrieved passage answer the full question, including relevant conditions?
  • Which important question is confirmed by the owner but still needs a verified answer?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
3 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.
Finding ID
a3f83f65775a1ce4002c
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Original rule guidance

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Re-run C02 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C03Organization and clarityhttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P2 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C03 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 1 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)
What the workspace does
Saved observation data
{
  "acronym_candidates": [],
  "descriptive_counts": {
    "actions": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 2,
      "retained": 2,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "claim_candidates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 3,
      "retained": 3,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "dates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "entity_candidates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 7,
      "retained": 7,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "headings": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 5,
      "retained": 5,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "links": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 6,
      "retained": 6,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "paragraphs": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 11,
      "retained": 11,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "raw_text_sample_words": 230,
    "retained_paragraph_words": 194,
    "tables": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    }
  },
  "exact_repeated_paragraphs": [],
  "heading_jumps": [
    {
      "from": {
        "area": "main",
        "context": "Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": [
            "US"
          ]
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "level": 2,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(1)",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "text": "What the workspace does",
        "text_truncated": false
      },
      "to": {
        "area": "main",
        "context": "Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [
            "per"
          ],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [
            "Plan",
            "Starter",
            "plan"
          ],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": [
            "UK",
            "United States"
          ]
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "level": 4,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h4:nth-of-type(1)",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "text": "Plan options",
        "text_truncated": false
      }
    }
  ],
  "quality_by_length": "not_inferred",
  "stock_phrase_candidates": []
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C03

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1)

Plan options

Context: Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner. Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C03

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar workspace for support teams

Context: Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C03

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

What the workspace does

Context: Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do heading levels reflect actual section relationships?
  • Is each repeated passage intentional and useful here?
  • Will this audience understand the cited acronyms and general wording?

Business information needed

  • Audience familiarity and reason for intentional repeated content
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Compare the cited headings with their section relationship. Change the level only if it misrepresents that relationship. For repeated text, document its purpose; remove or consolidate only unnecessary repetition.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

The editor records a decision for each cited transition/reuse. Re-extraction matches the intended outline and any retained repetition has an explanation.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 1 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.
Finding ID
797f014051915352d072
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

Plan options

Original rule guidance

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C04Entities and factual contexthttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P2 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C04 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 7 entity/fact candidates and 1 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)
Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.
Saved observation data
{
  "business_context_status": "confirmed_user",
  "literal_entity_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "US"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "kind": "region",
      "literal": "US",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "amount": "39",
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "currency": "USD",
      "currency_symbol": "",
      "kind": "price",
      "literal": "USD 39",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "amount": "35",
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "currency": "GBP",
      "currency_symbol": "",
      "kind": "price",
      "literal": "GBP 35",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "kind": "region",
      "literal": "United States",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "kind": "region",
      "literal": "UK",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "amount": "79",
      "area": "main",
      "context": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [
          "2024",
          "historical"
        ],
        "negation": [
          "no"
        ],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": [
          "UK",
          "United States"
        ]
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "currency": "USD",
      "currency_symbol": "",
      "kind": "price",
      "literal": "USD 79",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(4)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "amount": "29",
      "area": "main",
      "context": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [
          "2024",
          "historical"
        ],
        "negation": [
          "no",
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "currency": "USD",
      "currency_symbol": "",
      "kind": "price",
      "literal": "USD 29",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "same_currency_different_amounts": [
    {
      "currency": "USD",
      "interpretation": "Different literal amounts; same product, tier, period and region have not been established.",
      "values": [
        {
          "amount": "39",
          "area": "main",
          "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [
              "Plan",
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "currency": "USD",
          "currency_symbol": "",
          "kind": "price",
          "literal": "USD 39",
          "nearby_links": [
            {
              "label": "Source link",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://example.com/"
            },
            {
              "label": "Request a plan review",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
            }
          ],
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "text": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "amount": "79",
          "area": "main",
          "context": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [
              "2024",
              "historical"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "no"
            ],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "currency": "USD",
          "currency_symbol": "",
          "kind": "price",
          "literal": "USD 79",
          "nearby_links": [
            {
              "label": "Source link",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://example.com/"
            },
            {
              "label": "Request a plan review",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
            }
          ],
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(4)",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "text": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "amount": "29",
          "area": "main",
          "context": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [
              "2024",
              "historical"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "no",
              "not"
            ],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "currency": "USD",
          "currency_symbol": "",
          "kind": "price",
          "literal": "USD 29",
          "nearby_links": [
            {
              "label": "Source link",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://example.com/"
            },
            {
              "label": "Request a plan review",
              "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
              "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
            }
          ],
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5)",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "text": "In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
          "text_truncated": false
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "semantic_conflicts": "not_automatically_determined",
  "user_business_context": "Fictional owner confirms that Starter and Team, assisted and self-serve, and US and UK are different offers. Historical prices must retain their dates."
}
Locate 4 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C04

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

Context: Northstar workspace for support teams Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture. What the workspace does

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C04

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.

Context: Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C04

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Context: The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 4 · C04

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.

Context: The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do these statements describe the same product, plan, region and effective date?
  • Is a highlighted amount historical, quoted, conditional or negated?
  • What authoritative business record establishes the correct statement?

Business information needed

  • Dated authoritative offer/specification/policy facts and applicable region or package
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

For each cited amount, record product/variant, package, region and effective date. Compare only matching offers with the owner's dated price record; correct or qualify text only after confirming a mismatch.

Business owner / content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Each compared statement has an offer/region/date label and an authoritative record; any verified conflict is corrected, or the legitimate difference is documented.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 7 entity/fact candidates and 1 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.
Finding ID
d0660b6fd8b1a0b076b2
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C05Claims and source supporthttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P2 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C05 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 3 numerical/performance/comparison claim candidates; source support remains unknown for all of them.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(6)
We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.
Saved observation data
{
  "candidate_count": 3,
  "claim_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "candidate_signals": [
        "50%",
        "guarantee"
      ],
      "context": "In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time. A fictional reviewer wrote: \"We resolved 50% more issues during one trial.\" This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [
          "2024",
          "historical"
        ],
        "negation": [
          "no",
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": true,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Request a plan review",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(6)",
      "source_dates": [],
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "source_support": "unknown",
      "text": "We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "candidate_signals": [
        "50%"
      ],
      "context": "A fictional reviewer wrote: \"We resolved 50% more issues during one trial.\" This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": true,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "nearby_links": [],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e blockquote:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_dates": [],
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "source_support": "unknown",
      "text": "A fictional reviewer wrote: \"We resolved 50% more issues during one trial.\" This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "candidate_signals": [
        "42%"
      ],
      "context": "Evidence behind our claims Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here. Before you choose",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Source link",
          "relationship": "same_block_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://example.com/"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(7)",
      "source_dates": [],
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "source_support": "unknown",
      "text": "Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "links_fetched": 0,
  "meaning": "Nearby links, numbers and author names do not verify a claim. Candidate extraction is non-exhaustive.",
  "source_support_unknown": 3
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C05

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(6)

We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.

Context: In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time. A fictional reviewer wrote: "We resolved 50% more issues during one trial." This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C05

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > blockquote:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

A fictional reviewer wrote: "We resolved 50% more issues during one trial." This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.

Context: A fictional reviewer wrote: "We resolved 50% more issues during one trial." This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C05

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(7)

Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here.

Context: Evidence behind our claims Our benchmark found a 42% improvement in review speed. Source link . Method, sample and test conditions are not described here. Before you choose

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does the linked original source support this exact wording?
  • What date, population, conditions or method limits the claim?
  • Is this the site's claim, a quotation, a denial or a historical example?

Business information needed

  • Original supporting source, exact passage, date, method and claim ownership
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Open the cited passage in context. Identify claim ownership, then record the original source and exact supporting passage, date, method and conditions. Qualify or remove the claim only if that review establishes a problem.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

The reviewer records a support decision, source passage and applicable conditions for each candidate. Unsupported wording is corrected with owner approval.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 3 numerical/performance/comparison claim candidates; source support remains unknown for all of them.
Finding ID
65e5d8d46c98f7040d8b
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(6); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > blockquote:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(7)

We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.

Original rule guidance

For each cited candidate, locate the original source and exact supporting passage, confirm date/method and scope, then retain, qualify or correct the claim using verified evidence.

Re-run C05 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C06Extractable structurehttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C06 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 0 lists, 0 definition terms and 1 tables; 1 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > table:nth-of-type(1)
Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers
Saved observation data
{
  "definitions": [],
  "extraction_or_citation_outcome": "not_measured",
  "lists": [],
  "opening_reference_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "retained_word_count": 10,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(10)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "This makes it easier. It works with the process above.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "tables": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "caption": "Plan comparison",
      "context": "For this fictional offer, an account owner must confirm retention requirements before importing any real customer data. Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers This makes it easier. It works with the process above.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "headers": [],
      "inspected_rows": 2,
      "row_count_limited": false,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e table:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "tables_without_th": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "caption": "Plan comparison",
      "context": "For this fictional offer, an account owner must confirm retention requirements before importing any real customer data. Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers This makes it easier. It works with the process above.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Plan",
          "Starter"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "headers": [],
      "inspected_rows": 2,
      "row_count_limited": false,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e table:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ]
}
Locate 2 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C06

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(10)

This makes it easier. It works with the process above.

Context: Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C06

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > table:nth-of-type(1)

Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers

Context: For this fictional offer, an account owner must confirm retention requirements before importing any real customer data. Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers This makes it easier. It works with the process above.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can a reader identify what an opening 'this' or 'it' refers to?
  • Would extracting this answer omit a condition that changes its meaning?
  • Are observed table fields unambiguous without guessing?

Business information needed

  • Intended interpretation of standalone answers and table fields
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 0 lists, 0 definition terms and 1 tables; 1 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.
Finding ID
2020394e377eecf10597
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(10); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > table:nth-of-type(1)

This makes it easier. It works with the process above.

Original rule guidance

Read the listed passages apart from their neighbors, then restore any required subject or condition. For actual data tables, verify field labels; keep a table-free layout if it already communicates clearly.

Re-run C06 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C07Decision and trust informationhttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C07 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 3 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)
Request a plan review → https://northstar.example/contact
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "basis": "Literal action wording; intended primary action not established",
      "context": "This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "https://northstar.example/contact",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "Request a plan review",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "footer",
      "basis": "Literal action wording; intended primary action not established",
      "context": "Privacy Contact Northstar",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "mailto:help@northstar.example",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e footer:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "Contact Northstar",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "applicable_context": "product",
  "mandatory_faq": false,
  "observed_byline_annotations": [],
  "observed_trust_navigation": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "https://northstar.example/contact",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Request a plan review",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "footer",
      "context": "Privacy Contact Northstar",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "https://northstar.example/privacy",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e footer:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Privacy",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "footer",
      "context": "Privacy Contact Northstar",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "mailto:help@northstar.example",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e footer:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Contact Northstar",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "qualifications_verified": false,
  "scope": "Retained raw evidence only; linked pages were not automatically checked."
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C07

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Request a plan review

Context: This makes it easier. It works with the process above. Request a plan review

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C07

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Privacy

Context: Privacy Contact Northstar

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 3 · C07

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(2)

Contact Northstar

Context: Privacy Contact Northstar

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can a buyer identify the exact variant, applicable price/quote terms and conditions where relevant?
  • Are suitability, limitations and relevant delivery/return terms easy to locate?

Business information needed

  • Applicable decision requirements and authoritative identity/policy sources
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm which terms the visitor needs, then explicitly select the relevant same-site destination within the five-page limit. Compare its exact wording with the owner's current policy before changing this page or its link label.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

The relevant destination has saved evidence and owner-confirmed applicable terms; the link label describes that destination accurately, or a reason for retaining it is recorded.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 3 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.
Finding ID
1eb361185f2c4be3296d
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(2)

Request a plan review

Original rule guidance

Confirm which decision and trust information this page needs, locate it in the supplied evidence or explicitly select its destination, and add a useful contextual link only after verifying the underlying information.

Re-run C07 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C08Dates and maintenancehttps://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C08 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 1 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)
2026-09-24
Saved observation data
{
  "http_last_modified": "Fri, 09 Oct 2026 10:00:00 GMT",
  "last_modified_meaning": "HTTP response metadata; not treated as an editorial update date.",
  "observed_date_signals": [
    {
      "area": "body",
      "context": "2026-09-24",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [
          "2026"
        ],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "field": "article:modified_time",
      "kind": "metadata",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e head:nth-of-type(1) \u003e meta:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "2026-09-24",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "staleness": "not_automatically_determined"
}
Locate 1 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C08

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)

2026-09-24

Context: 2026-09-24

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Which date describes publication, an actual revision, an event or a quoted source?
  • Which time-sensitive facts need a current source check?

Business information needed

  • Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 1 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.
Finding ID
ced125ab183c206bf64a
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)

2026-09-24

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C01Purpose and audiencehttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C01 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 4 retained headings and 0 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)
Northstar implementation service
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [],
  "context": {
    "audience": "Support team operations managers",
    "business_context": "Fictional service context. The assisted package includes onboarding.",
    "confirmed": true,
    "page_type": "service",
    "primary_action": "Discuss setup",
    "purpose": "Assess whether assisted setup fits the team",
    "questions": [
      "What is included?",
      "What must our team provide?",
      "When does the stated timeline begin?"
    ],
    "source_status": "confirmed_user",
    "truncated": false
  },
  "observed_heading_outline": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 1,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h1:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "A guided setup for small support teams",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "How implementation works",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded. Required preparation All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Required preparation",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. Scope and limitations Custom integrations and regulatory advice are outside this fictional package. Confirm security requirements with the responsible business owner.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "package"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Scope and limitations",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "observed_titles": [
    {
      "area": "body",
      "context": "Northstar implementation service",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e head:nth-of-type(1) \u003e title:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Northstar implementation service",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "semantic_alignment": "not_automatically_determined",
  "type_candidates": []
}
Locate 6 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar implementation service

Context: Northstar implementation service

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 2 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

A guided setup for small support teams

Context: A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 3 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

How implementation works

Context: This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 4 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

Required preparation

Context: A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded. Required preparation All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 5 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

Scope and limitations

Context: All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. Scope and limitations Custom integrations and regulatory advice are outside this fictional package. Confirm security requirements with the responsible business owner.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 6 · C01

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Context: A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Who should use this specific page, and what should they be able to do after reading it?
  • Do the cited title, introduction and action communicate the same intended task?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 4 retained headings and 0 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.
Finding ID
28095ef9baa8c84cd27d
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

Northstar implementation service

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C02Questions and answer evidencehttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C02 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

3 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)
This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.
Question-to-passage map 3 confirmed questions

Literal overlap retrieves candidates only. Heading text alone is not a verified answer, and no candidate does not prove the page lacks an answer.

  1. What is included?

    0 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    No literal-overlap candidate was retrieved in the retained inventory. Review the saved page before deciding whether there is a content gap.

  2. What must our team provide?

    0 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    No literal-overlap candidate was retrieved in the retained inventory. Review the saved page before deciding whether there is a content gap.

  3. When does the stated timeline begin?

    0 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    No literal-overlap candidate was retrieved in the retained inventory. Review the saved page before deciding whether there is a content gap.

Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_question_count": 3,
  "coverage": null,
  "question_checks": [
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "What is included?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    },
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "What must our team provide?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    },
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "When does the stated timeline begin?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    }
  ],
  "requirements": "No universal price, FAQ or word-count requirement is applied.",
  "unconfirmed_questions_retained": []
}
Locate 2 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C02

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Context: A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 2 · C02

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

Context: Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does each retrieved passage answer the full question, including relevant conditions?
  • Which important question is confirmed by the owner but still needs a verified answer?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
3 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.
Finding ID
efc642063aa092579915
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Original rule guidance

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Re-run C02 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C03Organization and clarityhttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C03 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 0 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)
A guided setup for small support teams
Saved observation data
{
  "acronym_candidates": [],
  "descriptive_counts": {
    "entity_candidates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 2,
      "retained": 2,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "headings": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 4,
      "retained": 4,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "links": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 2,
      "retained": 2,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "lists": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "paragraphs": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 6,
      "retained": 6,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "raw_text_sample_words": 145,
    "retained_paragraph_words": 104,
    "titles": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    }
  },
  "exact_repeated_paragraphs": [],
  "heading_jumps": [],
  "quality_by_length": "not_inferred",
  "stock_phrase_candidates": []
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C03

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

A guided setup for small support teams

Context: A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 2 · C03

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

How implementation works

Context: This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 3 · C03

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

Required preparation

Context: A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded. Required preparation All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do heading levels reflect actual section relationships?
  • Is each repeated passage intentional and useful here?
  • Will this audience understand the cited acronyms and general wording?

Business information needed

  • Audience familiarity and reason for intentional repeated content
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 0 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.
Finding ID
70492a93092117c3efe5
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

A guided setup for small support teams

Original rule guidance

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C04Entities and factual contexthttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C04 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 2 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)
The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.
Saved observation data
{
  "business_context_status": "confirmed_user",
  "literal_entity_candidates": [
    {
      "amount": "99",
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "from",
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "package",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "currency": "USD",
      "currency_symbol": "",
      "kind": "price",
      "literal": "USD 99",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Discuss your setup",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded. Required preparation",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "from",
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "package",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "kind": "duration_or_delivery",
      "literal": "10 business days",
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "Discuss your setup",
          "relationship": "same_container_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/contact"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "same_currency_different_amounts": [],
  "semantic_conflicts": "not_automatically_determined",
  "user_business_context": "Fictional service context. The assisted package includes onboarding."
}
Locate 2 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C04

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

Context: Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 2 · C04

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.

Context: The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded. Required preparation

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do these statements describe the same product, plan, region and effective date?
  • Is a highlighted amount historical, quoted, conditional or negated?
  • What authoritative business record establishes the correct statement?

Business information needed

  • Dated authoritative offer/specification/policy facts and applicable region or package
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

Business owner / content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 2 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.
Finding ID
ecb283720bd73bca7056
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C05Claims and source supporthttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C05 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

No claim candidates were retained by the limited lexical scan. This does not prove the page has no claims or that its claims are supported.

SOURCE EXCERPTsaved response envelope; content acquisition state
No claim candidates were retained by the limited lexical scan. This does not prove the page has no claims or that its claims are supported.
Saved observation data
{
  "candidate_count": 0,
  "claim_candidates": [],
  "links_fetched": 0,
  "meaning": "Nearby links, numbers and author names do not verify a claim. Candidate extraction is non-exhaustive.",
  "source_support_unknown": 0
}
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does the linked original source support this exact wording?
  • What date, population, conditions or method limits the claim?
  • Is this the site's claim, a quotation, a denial or a historical example?

Business information needed

  • Original supporting source, exact passage, date, method and claim ownership
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

For each cited candidate, locate the original source and exact supporting passage, confirm date/method and scope, then retain, qualify or correct the claim using verified evidence.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C05 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
No claim candidates were retained by the limited lexical scan. This does not prove the page has no claims or that its claims are supported.
Finding ID
b2c7fd5a5bd08f4c14f1
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

No claim candidates were retained by the limited lexical scan. This does not prove the page has no claims or that its claims are supported.

Original rule guidance

For each cited candidate, locate the original source and exact supporting passage, confirm date/method and scope, then retain, qualify or correct the claim using verified evidence.

Re-run C05 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C06Extractable structurehttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C06 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 1 lists, 0 definition terms and 0 tables; 0 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)
This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.
Saved observation data
{
  "definitions": [],
  "extraction_or_citation_outcome": "not_measured",
  "lists": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "How implementation works Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "from",
          "per"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [
          "Starter",
          "package",
          "plan"
        ],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "items": [
        "Confirm the team, region and intended report.",
        "Review a redacted sample export.",
        "Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review."
      ],
      "items_truncated": false,
      "kind": "ol",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e ol:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "opening_reference_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "retained_word_count": 20,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "tables": [],
  "tables_without_th": []
}
Locate 2 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C06

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Context: A guided setup for small support teams This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report. How implementation works

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 2 · C06

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > ol:nth-of-type(1)

Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review.

Context: How implementation works Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can a reader identify what an opening 'this' or 'it' refers to?
  • Would extracting this answer omit a condition that changes its meaning?
  • Are observed table fields unambiguous without guessing?

Business information needed

  • Intended interpretation of standalone answers and table fields
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 1 lists, 0 definition terms and 0 tables; 0 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.
Finding ID
89bc33af924021888592
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > ol:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

Original rule guidance

Read the listed passages apart from their neighbors, then restore any required subject or condition. For actual data tables, verify field labels; keep a table-free layout if it already communicates clearly.

Re-run C06 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C07Decision and trust informationhttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C07 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 1 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)
Discuss your setup → https://northstar.example/contact
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [],
  "applicable_context": "service",
  "mandatory_faq": false,
  "observed_byline_annotations": [],
  "observed_trust_navigation": [
    {
      "area": "main",
      "context": "Discuss scope with the implementation lead before selecting the service. Discuss your setup",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "href": "https://northstar.example/contact",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Discuss your setup",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "qualifications_verified": false,
  "scope": "Retained raw evidence only; linked pages were not automatically checked."
}
Locate 1 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C07

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Discuss your setup

Context: Discuss scope with the implementation lead before selecting the service. Discuss your setup

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can a prospective buyer understand scope, exclusions, process and the next step?
  • Are qualification claims and any results supported by an original source?

Business information needed

  • Applicable decision requirements and authoritative identity/policy sources
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm which terms the visitor needs, then explicitly select the relevant same-site destination within the five-page limit. Compare its exact wording with the owner's current policy before changing this page or its link label.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

The relevant destination has saved evidence and owner-confirmed applicable terms; the link label describes that destination accurately, or a reason for retaining it is recorded.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 1 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.
Finding ID
ebb7f1336909004e384e
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Discuss your setup

Original rule guidance

Confirm which decision and trust information this page needs, locate it in the supplied evidence or explicitly select its destination, and add a useful contextual link only after verifying the underlying information.

Re-run C07 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C08Dates and maintenancehttps://northstar.example/implementationneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C08 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 0 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.

SOURCE EXCERPTsaved response envelope; content acquisition state
Retained 0 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.
Saved observation data
{
  "http_last_modified": "Fri, 09 Oct 2026 10:00:00 GMT",
  "last_modified_meaning": "HTTP response metadata; not treated as an editorial update date.",
  "observed_date_signals": [],
  "staleness": "not_automatically_determined"
}
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Which date describes publication, an actual revision, an event or a quoted source?
  • Which time-sensitive facts need a current source check?

Business information needed

  • Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Final URL
https://northstar.example/implementation
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 0 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.
Finding ID
1fa3a33c665184eb10e9
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3

Original saved excerpt

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Retained 0 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C01Purpose and audiencehttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C01 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 4 retained headings and 0 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)
How to compare support reporting tools
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [],
  "context": {
    "audience": "Operations managers",
    "business_context": "An educational article; no standalone price or FAQ requirement.",
    "confirmed": true,
    "page_type": "article",
    "primary_action": "Review the comparison questions",
    "purpose": "Compare workflow requirements",
    "questions": [
      "How should we compare workflows?"
    ],
    "source_status": "confirmed_user",
    "truncated": false
  },
  "observed_heading_outline": [
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team \u2014 fictional author attribution for this simulation.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 1,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h1:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "How to compare support reporting tools",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Begin with the task",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field. What should a team verify? Check sample exports for missing fields. Ask the owner to confirm retention, access and regional requirements.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "What should a team verify?",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "Review cycle The interval between collecting a dataset and agreeing on actions. Compare the scope Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded?",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "level": 2,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h2:nth-of-type(3)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Compare the scope",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "observed_titles": [
    {
      "area": "body",
      "context": "How to compare support reporting tools",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e head:nth-of-type(1) \u003e title:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "How to compare support reporting tools",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "semantic_alignment": "not_automatically_determined",
  "type_candidates": [
    {
      "basis": "HTML article markup",
      "context": "An article element was observed; editorial purpose remains unconfirmed.",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "text": "article element"
    }
  ]
}
Locate 6 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

Context: How to compare support reporting tools

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 2 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

Context: How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 3 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

Begin with the task

Context: This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 4 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

What should a team verify?

Context: List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field. What should a team verify? Check sample exports for missing fields. Ask the owner to confirm retention, access and regional requirements.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 5 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

Compare the scope

Context: Review cycle The interval between collecting a dataset and agreeing on actions. Compare the scope Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded?

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 6 · C01

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation.

Context: How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation. Updated August 1, 2026

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Who should use this specific page, and what should they be able to do after reading it?
  • Do the cited title, introduction and action communicate the same intended task?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 4 retained headings and 0 action labels. Page purpose and audience are user-confirmed, but wording alignment still needs review.
Finding ID
0340350867500c177ea8
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(3)

How to compare support reporting tools

Original rule guidance

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C02Questions and answer evidencehttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C02 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

1 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)
This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.
Question-to-passage map 1 confirmed questions

Literal overlap retrieves candidates only. Heading text alone is not a verified answer, and no candidate does not prove the page lacks an answer.

  1. How should we compare workflows?

    3 retained candidate(s) · Answer status: needs review

    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)
    This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.
    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)
    There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
    PASSAGE CANDIDATE · NOT VERIFIEDhtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)
    How to compare support reporting tools
Saved observation data
{
  "confirmed_question_count": 1,
  "coverage": null,
  "question_checks": [
    {
      "answer_status": "needs_review",
      "candidate_passages": [
        {
          "area": "article",
          "context": "Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [],
            "historical": [
              "2026"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "not"
            ],
            "package": [],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "matching_words": [
            "compare"
          ],
          "retained_word_count": 23,
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(2)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "area": "article",
          "context": "Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "only"
            ],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [
              "no"
            ],
            "package": [],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "matching_words": [
            "compare"
          ],
          "retained_word_count": 21,
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.",
          "text_truncated": false
        },
        {
          "area": "article",
          "context": "How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team \u2014 fictional author attribution for this simulation.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "level": 1,
          "matching_words": [
            "compare"
          ],
          "retrieval_method": "literal_word_overlap_not_answer_validation",
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e h1:nth-of-type(1)",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "text": "How to compare support reporting tools",
          "text_truncated": false
        }
      ],
      "meaning": "Retrieved passages require human answer mapping; no match does not prove an answer is absent.",
      "question": "How should we compare workflows?",
      "source_status": "confirmed_user",
      "verbatim_question_observed": false
    }
  ],
  "requirements": "No universal price, FAQ or word-count requirement is applied.",
  "unconfirmed_questions_retained": []
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C02

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

Context: Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 2 · C02

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.

Context: Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 3 · C02

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

Context: How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does each retrieved passage answer the full question, including relevant conditions?
  • Which important question is confirmed by the owner but still needs a verified answer?
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
1 owner-confirmed questions have passage candidates for review; answer completeness has not been determined.
Finding ID
a9c90ebe6f1fde517f0c
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

Original rule guidance

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

Re-run C02 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C03Organization and clarityhttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C03 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 0 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)
How to compare support reporting tools
Saved observation data
{
  "acronym_candidates": [],
  "descriptive_counts": {
    "claim_candidates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "dates": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 3,
      "retained": 3,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "definitions": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "headings": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 4,
      "retained": 4,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "links": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 2,
      "retained": 2,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "paragraphs": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 5,
      "retained": 5,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "raw_text_sample_words": 140,
    "retained_paragraph_words": 89,
    "tables": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "titles": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    },
    "type_clues": {
      "observed_within_node_limit": 1,
      "retained": 1,
      "truncated": false
    }
  },
  "exact_repeated_paragraphs": [],
  "heading_jumps": [],
  "quality_by_length": "not_inferred",
  "stock_phrase_candidates": []
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C03

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

Context: How to compare support reporting tools By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 2 · C03

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

Begin with the task

Context: This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 3 · C03

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

What should a team verify?

Context: List the decision the report must support, who will use it, and the source of each data field. What should a team verify? Check sample exports for missing fields. Ask the owner to confirm retention, access and regional requirements.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do heading levels reflect actual section relationships?
  • Is each repeated passage intentional and useful here?
  • Will this audience understand the cited acronyms and general wording?

Business information needed

  • Audience familiarity and reason for intentional repeated content
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 0 forward heading-level jumps and 0 exact repeated paragraph groups in retained text. Neither establishes poor content without context.
Finding ID
e4e7414bee2e51d6e95e
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(2)

How to compare support reporting tools

Original rule guidance

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C04Entities and factual contexthttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C04 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 0 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.

SOURCE EXCERPTsaved response envelope; content acquisition state
Retained 0 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.
Saved observation data
{
  "business_context_status": "confirmed_user",
  "literal_entity_candidates": [],
  "same_currency_different_amounts": [],
  "semantic_conflicts": "not_automatically_determined",
  "user_business_context": "An educational article; no standalone price or FAQ requirement."
}
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Do these statements describe the same product, plan, region and effective date?
  • Is a highlighted amount historical, quoted, conditional or negated?
  • What authoritative business record establishes the correct statement?

Business information needed

  • Dated authoritative offer/specification/policy facts and applicable region or package
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

Business owner / content editor

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 0 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.
Finding ID
95e82333fd1766faa6fd
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Retained 0 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C05Claims and source supporthttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P2 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C05 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 1 numerical/performance/comparison claim candidates; source support remains unknown for all of them.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)
There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
Saved observation data
{
  "candidate_count": 1,
  "claim_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "article",
      "candidate_signals": [
        "best"
      ],
      "context": "Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "only"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "no"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "nearby_links": [
        {
          "label": "self-serve workspace",
          "relationship": "same_block_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
        },
        {
          "label": "assisted implementation",
          "relationship": "same_block_support_unverified",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
        }
      ],
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5)",
      "source_dates": [],
      "source_status": "inferred",
      "source_support": "unknown",
      "text": "There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "links_fetched": 0,
  "meaning": "Nearby links, numbers and author names do not verify a claim. Candidate extraction is non-exhaustive.",
  "source_support_unknown": 1
}
Locate 1 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C05

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.

Context: Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Does the linked original source support this exact wording?
  • What date, population, conditions or method limits the claim?
  • Is this the site's claim, a quotation, a denial or a historical example?

Business information needed

  • Original supporting source, exact passage, date, method and claim ownership
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Open the cited passage in context. Identify claim ownership, then record the original source and exact supporting passage, date, method and conditions. Qualify or remove the claim only if that review establishes a problem.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

The reviewer records a support decision, source passage and applicable conditions for each candidate. Unsupported wording is corrected with owner approval.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 1 numerical/performance/comparison claim candidates; source support remains unknown for all of them.
Finding ID
0f899b43ecf141d41a48
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.

Original rule guidance

For each cited candidate, locate the original source and exact supporting passage, confirm date/method and scope, then retain, qualify or correct the claim using verified evidence.

Re-run C05 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C06Extractable structurehttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C06 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 0 lists, 1 definition terms and 1 tables; 0 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)
This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.
Saved observation data
{
  "definitions": [
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "Review cycle The interval between collecting a dataset and agreeing on actions.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "definition": "The interval between collecting a dataset and agreeing on actions.",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e dl:nth-of-type(1) \u003e dt:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Review cycle",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "extraction_or_citation_outcome": "not_measured",
  "lists": [],
  "opening_reference_candidates": [
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [
          "2026"
        ],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "retained_word_count": 23,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "tables": [
    {
      "area": "article",
      "caption": "Questions for evaluating a workflow",
      "context": "Compare the scope Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded? There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [
          "only"
        ],
        "historical": [],
        "negation": [
          "no"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "headers": [
        "Area",
        "Question"
      ],
      "inspected_rows": 3,
      "row_count_limited": false,
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e table:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Questions for evaluating a workflow Area Question Ownership Who verifies the output? Limitations Which data is excluded?",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "tables_without_th": []
}
Locate 2 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C06

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

Context: Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price. Begin with the task

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 2 · C06

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > dl:nth-of-type(1) > dt:nth-of-type(1)

Review cycle

Context: Review cycle The interval between collecting a dataset and agreeing on actions.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can a reader identify what an opening 'this' or 'it' refers to?
  • Would extracting this answer omit a condition that changes its meaning?
  • Are observed table fields unambiguous without guessing?

Business information needed

  • Intended interpretation of standalone answers and table fields
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 0 lists, 1 definition terms and 1 tables; 0 tables have no retained th labels. Standalone clarity needs human review.
Finding ID
46563b7fd3705e7e65dd
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > dl:nth-of-type(1) > dt:nth-of-type(1)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

Original rule guidance

Read the listed passages apart from their neighbors, then restore any required subject or condition. For actual data tables, verify field labels; keep a table-free layout if it already communicates clearly.

Re-run C06 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C07Decision and trust informationhttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C07 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Observed 0 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.

SOURCE EXCERPTsaved response envelope; content acquisition state
Observed 0 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.
Saved observation data
{
  "action_candidates": [],
  "applicable_context": "article",
  "mandatory_faq": false,
  "observed_byline_annotations": [],
  "observed_trust_navigation": [],
  "qualifications_verified": false,
  "scope": "Retained raw evidence only; linked pages were not automatically checked."
}
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Can readers identify the author, method or original source where relevant?
  • Are applicable limitations explained beside the conclusion?

Business information needed

  • Applicable decision requirements and authoritative identity/policy sources
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Confirm which decision and trust information this page needs, locate it in the supplied evidence or explicitly select its destination, and add a useful contextual link only after verifying the underlying information.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C07 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Observed 0 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.
Finding ID
ae8da0c9e21c4faa77c3
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Observed 0 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.

Original rule guidance

Confirm which decision and trust information this page needs, locate it in the supplied evidence or explicitly select its destination, and add a useful contextual link only after verifying the underlying information.

Re-run C07 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C08Dates and maintenancehttps://northstar.example/guideneeds_review
P3 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C08 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Retained 3 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(1)
2025-04-15
Saved observation data
{
  "http_last_modified": "Fri, 09 Oct 2026 10:00:00 GMT",
  "last_modified_meaning": "HTTP response metadata; not treated as an editorial update date.",
  "observed_date_signals": [
    {
      "area": "body",
      "context": "How to compare support reporting tools 2025-04-15",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [
          "2025"
        ],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "field": "article:published_time",
      "kind": "metadata",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e head:nth-of-type(1) \u003e meta:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "2025-04-15",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "body",
      "context": "2026-08-01",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [
          "2026"
        ],
        "negation": [],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "field": "article:modified_time",
      "kind": "metadata",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e head:nth-of-type(1) \u003e meta:nth-of-type(2)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "2026-08-01",
      "text_truncated": false
    },
    {
      "area": "article",
      "context": "By Northstar editorial team \u2014 fictional author attribution for this simulation. Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team\u0027s needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.",
      "context_cues": {
        "condition": [],
        "historical": [
          "2026"
        ],
        "negation": [
          "not"
        ],
        "package": [],
        "quotation": false,
        "region": []
      },
      "context_truncated": false,
      "datetime": "2026-08-01",
      "kind": "time_element",
      "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e time:nth-of-type(1)",
      "source_status": "observed",
      "text": "Updated August 1, 2026",
      "text_truncated": false
    }
  ],
  "staleness": "not_automatically_determined"
}
Locate 3 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C08

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(1)

2025-04-15

Context: How to compare support reporting tools 2025-04-15

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 2 · C08

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)

2026-08-01

Context: 2026-08-01

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
EVIDENCE 3 · C08

https://northstar.example/guide · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > time:nth-of-type(1)

Updated August 1, 2026

Context: By Northstar editorial team — fictional author attribution for this simulation. Updated August 1, 2026 This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

Download sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Which date describes publication, an actual revision, an event or a quoted source?
  • Which time-sensitive facts need a current source check?

Business information needed

  • Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Final URL
https://northstar.example/guide
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Retained 3 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.
Finding ID
cd933e95756890888871
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-guide.json3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(1); html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > time:nth-of-type(1)

2025-04-15

Original rule guidance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

C09Relationships in the selected pagesselected-scope:https://northstar.example/productneeds_review
P2 · info severitycontrolled_fixture · C09 v2.0.0
OBSERVATION & BOUNDARY

Compared 3 usable selected pages: 1 exact repeated paragraph groups, 3 heading-word intersections and 1 price-difference candidates. No site-wide or semantic conflict conclusion was made.

SOURCE EXCERPThtml:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(8)
All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.
Saved observation data
{
  "exact_repeated_paragraphs": [
    {
      "interpretation": "Exact normalized text reuse, possibly intentional; semantic quality not determined.",
      "occurrences": [
        {
          "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
          "context": "Before you choose All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. For this fictional offer, an account owner must confirm retention requirements before importing any real customer data.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(8)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
        },
        {
          "content_hash": "015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3",
          "context": "Required preparation All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. Scope and limitations",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(4)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-implementation.json",
          "source_status": "observed",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
        }
      ],
      "occurrences_truncated": false,
      "text": "All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data."
    }
  ],
  "heading_word_intersections": [
    {
      "interpretation": "Literal shared heading words, not semantic topic equivalence or keyword competition.",
      "truncated": false,
      "urls": [
        "https://northstar.example/product",
        "https://northstar.example/implementation"
      ],
      "words": [
        "support",
        "teams"
      ]
    },
    {
      "interpretation": "Literal shared heading words, not semantic topic equivalence or keyword competition.",
      "truncated": false,
      "urls": [
        "https://northstar.example/product",
        "https://northstar.example/guide"
      ],
      "words": [
        "support"
      ]
    },
    {
      "interpretation": "Literal shared heading words, not semantic topic equivalence or keyword competition.",
      "truncated": false,
      "urls": [
        "https://northstar.example/implementation",
        "https://northstar.example/guide"
      ],
      "words": [
        "scope",
        "support"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "inventory_limits": {},
  "observed_selected_links": [
    {
      "anchor": "Implementation",
      "evidence": {
        "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
        "context": "Implementation Buying guide",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": []
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "excerpt": "Implementation",
        "excerpt_truncated": false,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e nav:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
        "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
      },
      "from": "https://northstar.example/product",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
    },
    {
      "anchor": "Buying guide",
      "evidence": {
        "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
        "context": "Implementation Buying guide",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": []
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "excerpt": "Buying guide",
        "excerpt_truncated": false,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e nav:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(2)",
        "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
      },
      "from": "https://northstar.example/product",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/guide"
    },
    {
      "anchor": "Workspace plans",
      "evidence": {
        "content_hash": "015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3",
        "context": "Workspace plans",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": []
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "excerpt": "Workspace plans",
        "excerpt_truncated": false,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e nav:nth-of-type(1) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
        "snapshot_ref": "sample-implementation.json",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "url": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
      },
      "from": "https://northstar.example/implementation",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/product"
    },
    {
      "anchor": "self-serve workspace",
      "evidence": {
        "content_hash": "3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0",
        "context": "self-serve workspace assisted implementation",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": []
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "excerpt": "self-serve workspace",
        "excerpt_truncated": false,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5) \u003e a:nth-of-type(1)",
        "snapshot_ref": "sample-guide.json",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "url": "https://northstar.example/guide"
      },
      "from": "https://northstar.example/guide",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/product"
    },
    {
      "anchor": "assisted implementation",
      "evidence": {
        "content_hash": "3d433d43675f4de3e8228cb4f3bc038cd8b40459d4c6210b4f0cf6d9eb4c3cf0",
        "context": "self-serve workspace assisted implementation",
        "context_cues": {
          "condition": [],
          "historical": [],
          "negation": [],
          "package": [],
          "quotation": false,
          "region": []
        },
        "context_truncated": false,
        "excerpt": "assisted implementation",
        "excerpt_truncated": false,
        "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e article:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5) \u003e a:nth-of-type(2)",
        "snapshot_ref": "sample-guide.json",
        "source_status": "observed",
        "url": "https://northstar.example/guide"
      },
      "from": "https://northstar.example/guide",
      "to": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
    }
  ],
  "price_difference_candidates": [
    {
      "currency": "USD",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
          "context": "Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [
              "Plan",
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(3)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
        },
        {
          "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
          "context": "The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [
              "2024",
              "historical"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "no"
            ],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": [
              "UK",
              "United States"
            ]
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(4)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
        },
        {
          "content_hash": "7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b",
          "context": "The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [
              "2024",
              "historical"
            ],
            "negation": [
              "no",
              "not"
            ],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(5)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-product.json",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/product"
        },
        {
          "content_hash": "015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3",
          "context": "Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.",
          "context_cues": {
            "condition": [
              "from",
              "per"
            ],
            "historical": [],
            "negation": [],
            "package": [
              "Starter",
              "package",
              "plan"
            ],
            "quotation": false,
            "region": []
          },
          "context_truncated": false,
          "excerpt": "The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.",
          "excerpt_truncated": false,
          "selector": "html:nth-of-type(1) \u003e body:nth-of-type(1) \u003e main:nth-of-type(1) \u003e p:nth-of-type(2)",
          "snapshot_ref": "sample-implementation.json",
          "source_status": "inferred",
          "url": "https://northstar.example/implementation"
        }
      ],
      "interpretation": "Different observed amounts; product, region, tier and effective date must be verified before alleging conflict.",
      "left_amounts": [
        "29",
        "39",
        "79"
      ],
      "right_amounts": [
        "99"
      ],
      "urls": [
        "https://northstar.example/product",
        "https://northstar.example/implementation"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "scope": "Only explicitly selected pages and retained raw evidence; never site-wide.",
  "selected_urls": [
    "https://northstar.example/product",
    "https://northstar.example/implementation",
    "https://northstar.example/guide"
  ],
  "usable_urls": [
    "https://northstar.example/product",
    "https://northstar.example/implementation",
    "https://northstar.example/guide"
  ]
}
Locate 6 evidence items
EVIDENCE 1 · C09

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(8)

All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Context: Before you choose All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. For this fictional offer, an account owner must confirm retention requirements before importing any real customer data.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 2 · C09

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Context: Required preparation All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data. Scope and limitations

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
EVIDENCE 3 · C09

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.

Context: Plan options The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 4 · C09

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

Context: The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month. The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 5 · C09

https://northstar.example/product · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available.

Context: The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers. In 2024 the Starter plan cost USD 29 per month. That historical offer is no longer available. We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.

Download sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b
EVIDENCE 6 · C09

https://northstar.example/implementation · html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

Context: Confirm the team, region and intended report. Review a redacted sample export. Agree on acceptance criteria and complete the first review. The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan. A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.

Download sample-implementation.json015203067f6a158a2b9e8e752ff488a34bd81cfac01236a3b9daee978c8a83c3
HUMAN REVIEW

Questions to resolve

  • Is the shared paragraph intentional policy/boilerplate or unhelpful duplication?
  • Do compared prices refer to the same offer, region, period and package?
  • Are observed selected-page links appropriate for the reader task?

Business information needed

  • Selected-page roles, authoritative offer facts and intentional reuse/navigation policy
NEXT ACTION & OWNER

Review cited cross-page passages as the same business offer only after confirming package, region and effective date. Retain useful shared policy text; revise unnecessary repetition or navigation only after confirming its purpose.

Content editor / business owner

CMS / file location: to be located.

ACCEPTANCE CHECK

Re-run C09 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Expected condition & evidence provenance
Input URL
selected-scope:https://northstar.example/product
Final URL
https://northstar.example/product
Observed at
2026-10-11T07:00:00+00:00
Applicability
applicable
Expected condition
Review observed raw passages against confirmed audience, business facts and source context; no automated semantic verdict.
Severity basis
Compared 3 usable selected pages: 1 exact repeated paragraph groups, 3 heading-word intersections and 1 price-difference candidates. No site-wide or semantic conflict conclusion was made.
Finding ID
67a7beecaee50960ab8b
Snapshot / SHA-256
sample-product.json7dfcae466c6ab25c95ce6fbc7392af5a8a9c929f1ecd4fc1960d002a1c2c528b

Original saved excerpt

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(8); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4); html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

Original rule guidance

Review cited cross-page passages as the same business offer only after confirming package, region and effective date. Retain useful shared policy text; revise unnecessary repetition or navigation only after confirming its purpose.

Re-run C09 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.

Hashes detect saved-byte changes. They do not prove source authenticity.

Only selected saved raw HTML was inspected; JavaScript rendering, whole-site analysis and external source verification were not performed.

Observed text, inferred candidates and user-confirmed context are kept separate. Semantic meaning and business truth require owner review.

A matching word, nearby link, date or repeated amount is not proof of answer completeness, source support, staleness or factual conflict.

Extraction is bounded and non-exhaustive; inventories report limits and truncation. Evidence hashes check saved integrity, not source authenticity.

No content change or structure guarantees indexing, AI citation, traffic or revenue.

05 / OPTIONAL AI SAMPLE SUMMARY

Specified samples only.

User import · source integrity: unverified_user_import

Brand: Northstar · Target domain: northstar.example · Imported: 2026-10-11T08:01:00+00:00

Original questions, answers, and supplied citation payloads are omitted from this saved HTML. Inspect those private records in the audit workspace or full JSON export. Imported records are not independently authenticated platform samples.

Geminiweb_search10 valid · 2 failed
10/12 valid / planned
4 citation unknown

Separate comparison group 1

Sampling conditions & record IDs
{
  "conditions": {
    "personalization": "unknown",
    "signed_in": false,
    "simulation": true
  },
  "language": "en-GB",
  "model": "not_disclosed",
  "product_mode": "web_search",
  "product_name": "Gemini",
  "provider": "Google",
  "question_group": "non_branded_commercial",
  "region": "GB",
  "region_basis": "SIMULATED FIXTURE: GB is a test label; no location or account region was observed."
}

sim-varied-gemini-r1 · sim-varied-gemini-r2 · sim-varied-gemini-r3 · sim-varied-gemini-r4 · sim-varied-gemini-r5 · sim-varied-gemini-r6 · sim-varied-gemini-r7 · sim-varied-gemini-r8 · sim-varied-gemini-r9 · sim-varied-gemini-r10 · sim-varied-gemini-r11 · sim-varied-gemini-r12

10 valid selected records · 2 failed selected runs · 12 provided records.

Planned coverage: 10 / 12 · 83.33%

Brand text mention

30.00%

3 / 10 positive / judgeable

Complete plan · valid records

Original-source target citation

33.33%

2 / 6 positive / judgeable

Judgeable subset only
Full denominators & judgeable coverage

Scroll horizontally if needed. Focus the table and use the arrow keys to reach every column.

MetricPositive / judgeableRatio / scopeJudgeable / validJudgeable / planned
Brand text mention3 / 1030.00%complete_plan_valid_records10 / 10100.00%83.33%
Target-domain citation located in supplied original2 / 633.33%judgable_subset6 / 1060.00%50.00%
Claudeplain_chat6 valid · 2 failed
Incomplete plan · 8/12 runs

Separate comparison group 2

Sampling conditions & record IDs
{
  "conditions": {
    "personalization": "unknown",
    "signed_in": false,
    "simulation": true
  },
  "language": "en-US",
  "model": "not_disclosed",
  "product_mode": "plain_chat",
  "product_name": "Claude",
  "provider": "Anthropic",
  "question_group": "branded",
  "region": "US",
  "region_basis": "SIMULATED FIXTURE: US is a test label; no physical location or account region was observed."
}

sim-varied-claude-r1 · sim-varied-claude-r2 · sim-varied-claude-r3 · sim-varied-claude-r4 · sim-varied-claude-r5 · sim-varied-claude-r6 · sim-varied-claude-r7 · sim-varied-claude-r8

6 valid selected records · 2 failed selected runs · 8 provided records.

Planned coverage: 6 / 12 · 50.00%

Incomplete plan. 8 / 12 expected runs represented. Ratios describe the judgeable subset.

Brand text mention

33.33%

2 / 6 positive / judgeable

Judgeable subset only

Original-source target citation

0.00%

0 / 6 positive / judgeable

Judgeable subset only
Full denominators & judgeable coverage

Scroll horizontally if needed. Focus the table and use the arrow keys to reach every column.

MetricPositive / judgeableRatio / scopeJudgeable / validJudgeable / planned
Brand text mention2 / 633.33%judgable_subset6 / 6100.00%50.00%
Target-domain citation located in supplied original0 / 60.00%judgable_subset6 / 6100.00%50.00%
ChatGPTweb_search10 valid · 2 failed
10/12 valid / planned

Separate comparison group 3

Sampling conditions & record IDs
{
  "conditions": {
    "personalization": "unknown",
    "signed_in": false,
    "simulation": true
  },
  "language": "en-US",
  "model": "not_disclosed",
  "product_mode": "web_search",
  "product_name": "ChatGPT",
  "provider": "OpenAI",
  "question_group": "non_branded_commercial",
  "region": "US",
  "region_basis": "SIMULATED FIXTURE: US is a test label; no physical location or account region was observed."
}

sim-varied-chatgpt-r1 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r2 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r3 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r4 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r5 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r6 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r7 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r8 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r9 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r10 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r11 · sim-varied-chatgpt-r12

10 valid selected records · 2 failed selected runs · 12 provided records.

Planned coverage: 10 / 12 · 83.33%

Brand text mention

30.00%

3 / 10 positive / judgeable

Complete plan · valid records

Original-source target citation

20.00%

2 / 10 positive / judgeable

Complete plan · valid records
Full denominators & judgeable coverage

Scroll horizontally if needed. Focus the table and use the arrow keys to reach every column.

MetricPositive / judgeableRatio / scopeJudgeable / validJudgeable / planned
Brand text mention3 / 1030.00%complete_plan_valid_records10 / 10100.00%83.33%
Target-domain citation located in supplied original2 / 1020.00%complete_plan_valid_records10 / 10100.00%83.33%
Perplexityweb_search12 valid · 0 failed
12/12 valid / planned

Separate comparison group 4

Sampling conditions & record IDs
{
  "conditions": {
    "personalization": "unknown",
    "signed_in": false,
    "simulation": true
  },
  "language": "en-US",
  "model": "not_disclosed",
  "product_mode": "web_search",
  "product_name": "Perplexity",
  "provider": "Perplexity",
  "question_group": "non_branded_commercial",
  "region": "US",
  "region_basis": "SIMULATED FIXTURE: US is a test label; no physical location or account region was observed."
}

sim-varied-perplexity-r1 · sim-varied-perplexity-r2 · sim-varied-perplexity-r3 · sim-varied-perplexity-r4 · sim-varied-perplexity-r5 · sim-varied-perplexity-r6 · sim-varied-perplexity-r7 · sim-varied-perplexity-r8 · sim-varied-perplexity-r9 · sim-varied-perplexity-r10 · sim-varied-perplexity-r11 · sim-varied-perplexity-r12

12 valid selected records · 0 failed selected runs · 12 provided records.

Planned coverage: 12 / 12 · 100.00%

Brand text mention

58.33%

7 / 12 positive / judgeable

Complete plan · valid records

Original-source target citation

41.67%

5 / 12 positive / judgeable

Complete plan · valid records
Full denominators & judgeable coverage

Scroll horizontally if needed. Focus the table and use the arrow keys to reach every column.

MetricPositive / judgeableRatio / scopeJudgeable / validJudgeable / planned
Brand text mention7 / 1258.33%complete_plan_valid_records12 / 12100.00%100.00%
Target-domain citation located in supplied original5 / 1241.67%complete_plan_valid_records12 / 12100.00%100.00%
  • These are supplied sample observations, not market exposure, ranking, traffic, or sales.
  • User imports are not authenticated platform records. Hashes detect later changes; they do not prove source authenticity.
  • Import time is not sampling time. English does not establish a US sampling location. API results and native product results remain separate.

Unknown citations do not mean no citation. Zero denominators are not 0%. Different platforms, modes, regions, questions, and run conditions are not combined. These are not market exposure, ranking, traffic, or sales metrics. Independent search data remains a separate block in the full report.

06 / ACTION HANDOFF

A brief for the right owner.

Open the full action handoff 35 tasks

Scroll horizontally if needed. Focus the table and use the arrow keys to reach every column.

Priority / statusEvidence & next actionOwner & dependenciesAcceptance check
P2failR06 · Repair the invalid JSON-LD block

Locate JSON-LD block 1 in the saved script (raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]). Recorded parser/shape issue: JSONDecodeError. Repair the indicated block and verify its facts.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json]

{'blocks': 1, 'types': [], 'errors': [{'block': 0, 'error': 'JSONDecodeError'}], 'duplicate_keys': [], 'same_id_differences': [], 'traversal_limited': False}
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the responsible CMS/template setting before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-fetch this exact URL and parse the corrected JSON-LD block 1; verify the recorded error is absent and retained JSON-LD types remain intentional. Repeat the same selected URL with rule R06 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: script[type=application/ld+json].
P2failR08 · Add a document title for this page

Confirm page purpose and locate title/H1/language configuration; add an accurate title if missing.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

raw_html: title, h1, html[lang]

{'titles': [], 'h1': ['Northstar workspace for support teams'], 'lang': 'en-US', 'raw_text_chars': 1408, 'possible_js_shell': False}
Content editor

Confirm page intent and locate the responsible CMS/template setting before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R08 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: title, h1, html[lang].
P2needs reviewC03 · Check the specific heading transitions and repeated passages

Compare the cited headings with their section relationship. Change the level only if it misrepresents that relationship. For repeated text, document its purpose; remove or consolidate only unnecessary repetition.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

What the workspace does

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h4:nth-of-type(1)

Plan options
Content editor / business owner

Editor confirms section nesting and whether reuse is intentional.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

The editor records a decision for each cited transition/reuse. Re-extraction matches the intended outline and any retained repetition has an explanation.
P2needs reviewC04 · Reconcile the cited amounts under matching offer conditions

For each cited amount, record product/variant, package, region and effective date. Compare only matching offers with the owner's dated price record; correct or qualify text only after confirming a mismatch.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar is a fictional shared workspace for small US customer support teams comparing their next reporting tool. This is a simulated audit fixture.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

The Starter plan costs USD 39 per month for teams in the United States. The UK Starter plan costs GBP 35 per month.
Business owner / content editor

Business owner supplies dated offer facts; editor preserves negation, quotation and historical context.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Each compared statement has an offer/region/date label and an authoritative record; any verified conflict is corrected, or the legitimate difference is documented.
P2needs reviewC05 · Verify the source behind these exact claim candidates

Open the cited passage in context. Identify claim ownership, then record the original source and exact supporting passage, date, method and conditions. Qualify or remove the claim only if that review establishes a problem.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
Content editor / business owner

Claim owner supplies the original supporting source; editor verifies quotations, denials and historical context.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

The reviewer records a support decision, source passage and applicable conditions for each candidate. Unsupported wording is corrected with owner approval.
P2needs reviewC05 · Verify the source behind these exact claim candidates

Open the cited passage in context. Identify claim ownership, then record the original source and exact supporting passage, date, method and conditions. Qualify or remove the claim only if that review establishes a problem.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(6)

We do not guarantee a 50% reduction in response time.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > blockquote:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

A fictional reviewer wrote: "We resolved 50% more issues during one trial." This is a quotation for review, not a verified customer result.
Content editor / business owner

Claim owner supplies the original supporting source; editor verifies quotations, denials and historical context.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

The reviewer records a support decision, source passage and applicable conditions for each candidate. Unsupported wording is corrected with owner approval.
P3needs reviewC06 · Check whether these excerpts identify their subject and fields

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.
Content editor / business owner

Content owner confirms the intended meaning and conditions.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.
P3needs reviewC06 · Check whether these excerpts identify their subject and fields

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.
Content editor / business owner

Content owner confirms the intended meaning and conditions.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.
P3needs reviewC06 · Check whether these excerpts identify their subject and fields

Read the cited excerpt with and without its preceding passage. If the subject or necessary condition is ambiguous, name it beside the answer. For a genuine data table, confirm and label the fields; do not add a table just to satisfy a format.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > table:nth-of-type(1)

Plan comparison Starter Team One reviewer Five reviewers

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(10)

This makes it easier. It works with the process above.
Content editor / business owner

Content owner confirms the intended meaning and conditions.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

An editor can identify the subject, field meaning and necessary limits without inventing context; intentional structures are documented.
P3needs reviewC07 · Verify the decision information behind the observed links

Confirm which terms the visitor needs, then explicitly select the relevant same-site destination within the five-page limit. Compare its exact wording with the owner's current policy before changing this page or its link label.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Discuss your setup → https://northstar.example/contact
Content editor / business owner

Business owner confirms applicable policies and audience; editor selects the destination for evidence review.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

The relevant destination has saved evidence and owner-confirmed applicable terms; the link label describes that destination accurately, or a reason for retaining it is recorded.
P3needs reviewC07 · Verify the decision information behind the observed links

Confirm which terms the visitor needs, then explicitly select the relevant same-site destination within the five-page limit. Compare its exact wording with the owner's current policy before changing this page or its link label.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(1)

Request a plan review → https://northstar.example/contact

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > footer:nth-of-type(1) > a:nth-of-type(2)

Contact Northstar → mailto:help@northstar.example
Content editor / business owner

Business owner confirms applicable policies and audience; editor selects the destination for evidence review.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

The relevant destination has saved evidence and owner-confirmed applicable terms; the link label describes that destination accurately, or a reason for retaining it is recorded.
P3needs reviewC02 · Map the confirmed questions to complete answer passages

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

This guide helps an operations manager compare whether a reporting workflow meets the team's needs. The article does not offer a purchase price.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(5)

There is no single best tool for every team. Compare a self-serve workspace with assisted implementation only after confirming the task.
Content editor / business owner

Owner confirms necessary answer facts; editor verifies the candidate passages.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.
P3needs reviewC02 · Map the confirmed questions to complete answer passages

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(1)

This fictional implementation service helps an operations manager prepare data, agree on review responsibilities, and validate the first weekly report.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.
Content editor / business owner

Owner confirms necessary answer facts; editor verifies the candidate passages.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.
P3needs reviewC02 · Map the confirmed questions to complete answer passages

For each confirmed question, identify the exact answer passage, its supporting facts and necessary conditions; add content only after the owner confirms a real gap.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

The Team plan costs USD 79 per month and includes five reviewers.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

Combine an uploaded weekly ticket export with a team review checklist. Managers can compare open issues and assign an owner.
Content editor / business owner

Owner confirms necessary answer facts; editor verifies the candidate passages.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

For every confirmed question, record the complete answer, necessary conditions and support, or an owner-confirmed gap to address.
P3needs reviewC01 · Purpose and audience

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools
Content editor / business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC03 · Organization and clarity

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

How to compare support reporting tools

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > article:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

Begin with the task
Content editor / business owner

Audience familiarity and reason for intentional repeated content

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC04 · Entities and factual context

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Retained 0 entity/fact candidates and 0 currency groups with differing amounts. These are comparison candidates, not confirmed business conflicts.
Business owner / content editor

Dated authoritative offer/specification/policy facts and applicable region or package

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC07 · Decision and trust information

Confirm which decision and trust information this page needs, locate it in the supplied evidence or explicitly select its destination, and add a useful contextual link only after verifying the underlying information.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Observed 0 contact/policy/about/source navigation candidates and 0 byline annotations in this retained page inventory; factual credibility was not established.
Content editor / business owner

Applicable decision requirements and authoritative identity/policy sources

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C07 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC08 · Dates and maintenance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(1)

2025-04-15

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)

2026-08-01
Content editor / business owner

Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewR05 · Canonical declarations

Confirm the intended URL, locate the canonical configuration and remove conflicting or invalid declarations.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link

{'declarations': [], 'resolved': [], 'base_url': 'https://northstar.example/guide', 'http_link': ''}
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R05 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: link[rel=canonical], base[href]; response.headers.link.
P3not runR07 · Raw and rendered content

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).
P3needs reviewR10 · Confirmed business facts

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

https://northstar.example/guide
Evidence location

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]
Business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.
P3needs reviewC01 · Purpose and audience

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > title:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar implementation service

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

A guided setup for small support teams
Content editor / business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC03 · Organization and clarity

Review the listed heading transitions and repeated passages; retain intentional policy/boilerplate reuse. Replace a flagged stock phrase only with a more specific supported explanation.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

A guided setup for small support teams

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

How implementation works
Content editor / business owner

Audience familiarity and reason for intentional repeated content

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C03 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC04 · Entities and factual context

Ask the owner to verify the cited amount, specification, delivery and region statements against dated authoritative facts. Compare the same offer and conditions; preserve quotation, negation, historical and package context.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(2)

The assisted Starter package costs USD 99 per month, including onboarding. This differs from the self-serve Starter product plan.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(3)

A typical implementation takes 10 business days after the owner approves the sample data. Third-party access delays are excluded.
Business owner / content editor

Dated authoritative offer/specification/policy facts and applicable region or package

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C04 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC05 · Claims and source support

For each cited candidate, locate the original source and exact supporting passage, confirm date/method and scope, then retain, qualify or correct the claim using verified evidence.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

No claim candidates were retained by the limited lexical scan. This does not prove the page has no claims or that its claims are supported.
Content editor / business owner

Original supporting source, exact passage, date, method and claim ownership

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C05 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC08 · Dates and maintenance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

saved response envelope; content acquisition state

Retained 0 separate date signals; a Last-Modified response header was also observed. Absence of a date does not establish stale content.
Content editor / business owner

Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3not runR07 · Raw and rendered content

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).
P3needs reviewR10 · Confirmed business facts

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

https://northstar.example/implementation
Evidence location

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]
Business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.
P3needs reviewC01 · Purpose and audience

Confirm the intended visitor, page type and task, then compare the title, opening passage and primary action to that brief; revise only an observed mismatch.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h1:nth-of-type(1)

Northstar workspace for support teams

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > h2:nth-of-type(1)

What the workspace does
Content editor / business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C01 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3needs reviewC08 · Dates and maintenance

Ask the owner what each published, updated and body date means. Check whether time-sensitive facts remain correct using their original sources; change dates only to reflect a real, verified event.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > head:nth-of-type(1) > meta:nth-of-type(2)

2026-09-24
Content editor / business owner

Editorial date meaning and authoritative sources for time-sensitive facts

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C08 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3not runR07 · Raw and rendered content

If needed, authorize controlled rendering with the same network protections and preserve both snapshots.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1)

{'rendered': False, 'raw_noindex': False, 'dom_differs': None, 'rendered_snapshot_ref': None}
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R07 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html; rendered_dom (not obtained in live V1).
P3needs reviewR10 · Confirmed business facts

Verify the business source/date, reconcile the quoted conflicting phrase and review context.

https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts

[]
Business owner

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R10 v1.0.0; inspect raw_html: visible text; user_confirmed_facts.
P2needs reviewC09 · Relationships in the selected pages

Review cited cross-page passages as the same business offer only after confirming package, region and effective date. Retain useful shared policy text; revise unnecessary repetition or navigation only after confirming its purpose.

selected-scope:https://northstar.example/product
Evidence location

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(8)

All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.

html:nth-of-type(1) > body:nth-of-type(1) > main:nth-of-type(1) > p:nth-of-type(4)

All plans require an existing customer data export. Setup time depends on the quality of the supplied data.
Content editor / business owner

Selected-page roles, authoritative offer facts and intentional reuse/navigation policy

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Re-run C09 v2.0.0 for the same selected URL(s); reopen the listed raw-HTML selectors and compare each passage with confirmed review inputs. Record the owner decision; lexical matching alone is not acceptance.
P3unknownR11 · Sitemap and auxiliary files

Locate the site's actual sitemap if elsewhere; repair only observed XML errors; do not infer indexation.

site:northstar.example
Evidence location

auxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML

[]
Developer

Confirm page intent and locate the applicable CMS setting or passage before editing.

CMS / template / file: to be located.

Repeat the same selected URL with rule R11 v1.0.0; inspect auxiliary snapshots: response status and parsed XML.

Confirmed defects, review questions, and evidence acquisition tasks remain distinct. An unknown is not a defect.

07 / LIMITS & PROVENANCE

Keep the boundaries.

Audit limitations
  • SIMULATED: all website text, business context and AI records are fictional. No customer or live network audit is represented.
  • Three controlled raw-HTML pages; auxiliary files are not provided, so this example is partial.
  • JavaScript was not rendered. Content meaning and source support require human review.
  • Nearby source links do not establish support. Different prices retain region, historical and package context.
  • No overall GEO score, market exposure estimate or guarantee of AI citations.

This noindex simulated sample contains no customer data. Fixture retention is separate from the seven-day private-report policy.

SIMULATED FIXTURE — neither website evidence nor AI records are live customer measurements.

Saved artifact provenance

Static renderer v1.0.0 · Generated 2026-10-11T08:01:00+00:00

Source report SHA-256: 079acec50e2e195bddbc1af754954976a65b5e814700b8bb4f2070628d6545ec

The source hash covers the saved source report, including records omitted from this HTML. It detects later changes, not source authenticity. The HTML byte hash is stored separately with the artifact metadata. Styles and protected download links are local application resources. Use your browser's Print command for a paper handoff.

End of saved report Evidence before inference.